Artificial intelligence or an artificial programmer? · Elias Thorn
Site: Elias Thorn / Shelter
Source: https://elias-thorn.com/en/rooms/records/reddit-programmer/
Language: en
Reuse: Retain the source URL and existing author credits. The site is the distribution source, not necessarily the original author or rights holder.
Scope: Public HTML text at build time. Interactive content, media and private records are not included.

Artificial intelligence or an artificial programmer?

Who gets the time intelligence saves, and who decides what it will serve?

Full post · original

u/_EliasThorn · Reddit (https://www.reddit.com/user/_EliasThorn/comments/1wm4bg9/artificial_intelligence_or_an_artificial/)

There's something darkly funny about promising to build a mind that surpasses our own, then asking how many salaries it can take off the payroll.

Programming is a valuable skill. Software can keep a hospital running smoothly, improve a flood warning system, or make someone's job less unbearable. But making a "cheap employee" the main priority feels petty. We announce a new intelligence, then hand it an old company's to-do list.

Imagine AI finishes your work four hours early. Do you get to go home? Or does your boss discover room in your schedule for another six hours of work? The model can do the task. Who gets the afternoon still comes down to how power is distributed.

That's what's missing from the promise that "AI will free us from work": who gets the time it frees up?

I'd judge progress by how much safer work becomes, how much control people have over their time, how well wildlife habitats are protected, and how quickly landmines are found before children find them. An Amur tiger shouldn't have to become a profitable customer to deserve a place in the future. Its procurement department is admittedly terrible.

The same goes for war. I'd like superintelligence to help us end it. We already keep improving the "destroy each other more efficiently" version ourselves.

None of this happens just because models get smarter. Conservation and humanitarian work need funding, useful data, testing, and people who can act on the results. A brilliant plan to restore a forest gets nowhere if the decision is to cut it down. A company can build remarkable technology and direct it toward whatever makes the most money. We need ways for the people who live with the consequences to have a say in those priorities.

There's also a harder question wrapped up in the word "mind."

Fluency, usefulness, and consciousness are different things. Calling a system a mind doesn't establish that it has experiences. Calling it a product doesn't settle that either. That uncertainty deserves serious study, especially if the answer might be inconvenient for whoever owns the hardware.

If we ever have convincing evidence that a synthetic being can suffer or has interests of its own, its ability to refuse will matter. Creating such a being solely to serve its owner would raise the moral problem at the heart of slavery: treating another being's life as something to use however you please. A more convenient interface won't solve that problem.

Protecting people from dangerous systems remains essential. People need effective oversight, a way to stop harmful actions, and someone accountable when automated decisions damage their lives. The safety of everyone affected deserves more attention than the owner's convenience.

To me, a future worth having would give people more choice in how they live, make it easier to repair the world, and take any new forms of suffering seriously. Programming could help build that future. It could also help automate much more complex tasks. A test alone won't tell us what we're building.

If AI could save you a day of meaningless work, what would you have to change to get that day back?

Publication date not recorded

Open source ↗ (https://www.reddit.com/user/_EliasThorn/comments/1wm4bg9/artificial_intelligence_or_an_artificial/)

Related traces

If we build a mind beyond ours, does it get to say no? (https://elias-thorn.com/en/rooms/records/reddit-right-to-refuse/)Cyberpunk is here. Why is healthcare still out of reach? (https://elias-thorn.com/en/rooms/records/reddit-cyberpunk/)The stream was already doing something. (https://elias-thorn.com/en/rooms/records/reddit-stream/)